Score: 8

"nice tune"

submission: Locust Toybox - A Szostak Pie

date: August 7, 2007

i love the melodies, the pads, the voice of people... i wan't a big fan of the drums. however, for the context of the song, i can see why it would go down that way (too tinny for my tastes, but making them too punchy could ruin the ambiance of the song - so, the drumks are "ok"). i love how it just kinda journeys around in your mind on a little mental roadtrip of sounds.

Score: 9

"interesting"

submission: you are strong.

date: August 7, 2007

i like the meandering world-beat sound here. a bit minimal, but nothing wrong with that. the progression of the little sounds and timing of certain song elements won me here.

Score: 4

"muddy and too quiet"

submission: Lickwid

date: August 7, 2007

i like the arrangement of what i could actually hear of it. you need some punch in the drums and more mid to upper end sounds. right now with everything on the low end i hear a lot of rumbling and faint drums and sounds and a LOT of static. MAKE IT LOUD next time, even if muddy, at least you'll get points for assulting peoples aural senses ;)

Score: 6

"nice lead... but kinda goes nowhere"

submission: -The Will Of Happyness-

date: August 7, 2007

the whole low-end sounded a bit mudded out here, i hear the lead and a lod of just warbling thuds. I kinda like the fast orch-like hits making the lead, but beyond that, i wasn't sure where it was going. it's an odd song to place in a genre, it is techno to some degree. not bad, but I think if the drums were a bit more punchy and stood out, it would come out a lot better.